Experience the other side of history.
Ghost Hunting at Historic Palmyra
Immerse yourself in the exhilarating late-night experiences at the William Phelps General Store and the captivating 23-room Palmyra Historical Museum, where history reveals its hidden secrets. Each room holds an air of mystery that can send shivers down your spine—prepare to be thrilled by unexpected whispers, footsteps, or even a gentle touch that defies explanation. Join the ranks of many adventurous groups who have encountered eerie noises and ghostly apparitions, captured remarkable photographs, and pursued phantom cats, only to find themselves in a realm where the unexplained thrives.
Whether you’re a novice or a seasoned ghost hunter, Historic Palmyra’s museums promise to ignite your passion and satisfy your every paranormal curiosity.
Our location has drawn the attention of renowned paranormal investigators and television shows, including Kindred Spirits, Ghost Finders, Ghost Detectives, Haunted Explorations, A&E’s “My Ghost Story,” “This Old Haunted House,” “Scared and Alone,” Pittsburgh Paranormal, Roc City Paranormal, PBI, SPI, Beyond Ghosts, Crossroads, G.H.O.S.T., Salt City Paranormal, Ghost Seekers, New York Paranormal, Scientific Paranormal Investigations, Soul Searchers, WNY Paranormal, P.I.T. Crew, GOWNY, Elmira Paranormal, Rochester Phantom Hunters, Dark Echoes, and Paraflixx. Experience the thrill for yourself—who knows what you might encounter in the shadows?
Paranormal Investigations
Beginner Investigation: 4 hr.. Private Ghost Hunt: 2 buildings, tour, $200, minimum of 1- 5 people. Once the minimum is met, $40 per person. Time slots vary
Weekend Warrior: 5 hr. Private Ghost Hunt: 2 buildings, tour, $300, minimum of 1-6 people. Once the minimum is met, $50 per person. Time slots vary
ADD ONS: Guided tour to the “old cemetery”, weather permitting: $50
Sheet pizza (32 slices) from Marks or Nimas: $50
Additional investigation hour: $100
A $60 non-refundable deposit is required at booking.
Historic Palmyra reserves the right to refuse service and/or remove individuals from the private property if they are being disruptive, are highly intoxicated, or suspected of being under the influence of illegal drugs.
Will you be next?
Ghost hunts can be scheduled year-round and are private to your group (unless you choose otherwise).
Investigations can be tailored to your group and experience level. Groups are given a tour by a guide who can share stories or keep the history secret, only to verify your findings. Bring some snacks for your group, and our central meeting area will serve as the base for your group and a resting spot.
We also host birthday parties and special events. Gift certificates are also available!
Please call (315) 597-6981 or email historicpalmyra@gmail.com for information and scheduling. If you would like history on our locations, feel free to call our office or send us an email.
You can check our calendar for availability only. We try to keep this calendar as up-to-date as possible. Please call us if you are interested in booking one of our open dates.
Testimonials.
We consistently maintain 5 stars on all of our Travelocity pages.
Museum staff member, Steve B, reported seeing a full body apparition of Sibyl Phelps who reminded him sternly, “Don’t touch my stuff.”
Joanne A saw the figure of a little girl in the upstairs of the Phelps residence.
Many have felt the touch of the hands of a young girl in the Phelps living room.
“A fear of dread engulfed me,” said Rob Henning, co-founder and case manager for Scientific Paranormal Investigators.
“I swear a black cat came in front of the door of the Phelps Store, walked down through the store and up the stairs,” said Ralph Kommer.
“I was locked out of the Phelps Store by Mayme Phelps,” exclaimed docent Andrew Lambrix, who is always checking over his shoulder, to this day.
“The children who passed away in the fire in 1964 are always opening cabinets and moving items around,” shared Kathryn Woodlock.
Features.
Check out Until Dawn Paranormal's Investigation of Historic Palmyra here!
Historic Palmyra made the list of "7 of the Most Haunted Places in New York State." See the article here!
We are featured in Season 3, Episode 10 of My Ghost Story!
Check out our episode of Ghost Finders on the Spirit Channel on Roku.
We are featured in Season 2, Episode 2 of Within These Walls on VIDI Space.
View our live feeds from the World’s Largest Ghost Hunt in 2018 here.
Follow us on social media for updates on paranormal events and activity at Historic Palmyra:
